How can one possibly generalize about the practice of. Toward a politics of peace persists in its relevance these many years after is first publication. Subscribe to this free journal for more curated articles on this topic. Toward a politics of peace remains a strange work in terms of genre some twenty years after its initial publication. Sara ruddicks maternal thinking as weaving epistemology for justpeace. The year 2009 marks twenty years since the publication of sara ruddicks monumental text maternal thinking. Ruddick attempted to respond to these critiques in the 1995 edition of maternal thinking, but how successfully she was able to enter fully into an interactive engagement with them remains an open question. Sara ruddicks 1980 first work on maternal thinking was. However, this did open the way to what we might describe as a fourth wave of maternal scholarship that attempts that interactive engagement. Maternal thinking and the concept of vulnerability in security paradigms, policies, and practices carol cohn university of massachusetts boston, usa abstract this article takes as its starting point sara ruddick s discussion of vulnerability in her 1989 groundbreaking book maternal thinking. I make little use of psychology, more of literature, in thinking about the kinds of cognitive sex differences i discuss.
Pdf the most popular uniting theme in feminist peace literature grounds womens. Maternal feminism is the belief of many early feminists that women as mothers and caregivers had an important but distinctive role to play in society and in politics. Toward a politics of peace by sara ruddick while editing the book maternal thinking. Dislocating the commu nity, ethics 99 january i989. Toward a politics of peace article pdf available january 2010 with 205 reads how we measure. Towards a politics of peace in maternal thinking, towards a politics of peace 1989, sarah ruddick uses her considerable experience and skill as a philosopher to explicate an analysis of mothering as a practice. Sara ruddicks maternal thinking as weaving epistemology for.
It was a widespread philosophy among welltodo women in the british empire, particularly canada, from the late 19th century. Rethinking ruddick and the ethnocentrism critique of maternal thinking. This book is useful not only for feminist thinkers but for anyone interested in the development of another perspective on the militaristic consciousness that is rampant in todays industrialized and militarized societies. Peacebuilding as mothering does one have to be a mother. Toward a politics of peace persists in its relevance these.
Ruddick argues that the practice of mothering engenders a certain style of thought maternal thinking. Scholars who focus solely on maternal thinking or even the work of mothering obscure the fact that such work is just her prime example of the reconceptualized notion of work she. Ruddick s central thesis, that maternal thinking develops strategies for preserving the life of the child, fostering the childs growth, and shaping an acceptable child, is applied to the intersecting influences of famine memory, religion, education, and emigration in postfamine ireland. It incorporates reform ideas from social feminism, and combines the concepts of maternalism and feminism. Toward a politics of peace, a book that is regarded, along with adrienne richs of woman. But the fundamental significance of this relationship for moral philosophy has only recently begun to be explored philosophically, as for example in the work of sara ruddick 1982. Sara ruddicks maternal thinking as weaving epistemology. Philosophy, politics, and practice which was published in commemoration of the 20th anniversary of ruddicks book.
Alannah ireland franklin community school, vancouver, bc doi. She notes that engaging in the practice of mothering incites most to resist their violent impulses, and to break free of familial cycles of violence. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. A new york times notable book of the year 1989 philosopher, mother, and feminist sara ruddick examines the discipline of mothering, showing for the first time how the daytoday work of raising children gives rise to distinctive ways of t. Sage reference maternal thinking ruddick sage knowledge. A few years ago i was interviewing people for a book i was undertaking about the relationship between motherhood and feminism. Psychologists are not, so far as i know, talking about women who have empathically identified with and assimilated maternal practices, either by engaging in. Building on sara ruddicks work, we argue that her maternal thinking can be understood as a feminist weaving epistemology or flexible way of knowing that promotes meaningful inclusion, symmetrical power relations, and positive peace through three major practices. Maternal thinking the consortium on gender, security and human.
Ruddick theorized that maternal thinking affects moral reasoning. Almost every feminist scholar or researcher i talked to said, you must read sara ruddicks maternal thinking. The article presents the authors opinions the legacy of the book maternal thinking. Project muse reflections on sara ruddicks maternal thinking. A critical analysis of sara ruddicks maternal thinking. Could it be, rich asked, that women are even now thinking in ways which traditional intel lection denies, decries or is unable to grasp.
Feminist solidarity, according to ruddick, forms through struggles to work. The most popular uniting theme in feminist peace literature grounds womens peace work in mothering. Ruddicks central thesis, that maternal thinking develops strategies for preserving the life of the child, fostering the childs growth, and shaping an acceptable child, is applied to the intersecting influences of famine memory, religion, education, and emigration in postfamine ireland. Maternal peace politics free online course materials. Thirty years ago, in the late 1970s, i spent some time hovering over a possibility suggested by adrienne rich in of woman born.
What madematernal thinking so lifechanging and groundbreaking was that it foregrounded what. On maternal thinking by ruddick, sara womens studies. A new york times notable book of the year 1989philosopher, mother, and feminist sara ruddick examines the discipline of mothering, showing for the first time how the daytoday work of raising children gives rise to distinctive ways of thinking. The year 2009 marks twenty years since the publication of sara ruddick s monumental text maternal thinking. February 17, 1935 march 20, 2011 was a feminist philosopher and the author of maternal thinking. Start studying philosophy chapter 5 true and false. Despite these glowing endorsements, i hesitated to read the book then because i feared her ideas might make my premise redundant. Pdf on feb 1, 2014, fiona robinson and others published. Ruddick argues that the practice of mothering engenders a certain style of thoughtmaternal thinking. Toward a politics of peace, a book that is regarded, along with adrienne richs of woman born, as the most significant work in maternal scholarship and the new field of motherhood studies. Ruddick describes mothering as a practice that is open to men and women and does not have a necessary link to giving birth. Ruddicks maternal thinking offers a different perspective to the idea of the maternal female stereotype which tends to be largely discredited in academia although perhaps remains more acceptable in societal rhetoric and challenges how we think about the relationship between mothering and peace. I argue if maternal arguments do not address the variety of relationships different races and classes of mothers have to institutional violence andor the military, then the resulting peace politics can only draw incomplete conclusions about the relationships between maternal workthinking and. On maternal winking sara ruddick thirty years ago, in the late 1970s, i spent some time hovering over a pos sibility suggested by adrienne rich in of woman born.
Maternal thinking as a feminist standpoint mothers and mens wars maternal nonviolence. In maternal thinking, sara ruddick constructs a ground. Ruddicks work on maternal thinking has often been used, misused, and mischarac. Enter your mobile number or email address below and well send you a link to download the free kindle app. Maternal thinking available for download and read online in other formats. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. The concept of maternal thinking was put forward in philosopher sara ruddicks 1989 book maternal thinking. Pdf maternal thinking download full pdf book download. Her discussion of maternal thinking could be a bit clearer what exactly is maternal thinking. A really good book about mothering, mothers, maternal thinking, and peace. Alcoff also challenges ruddicks notion of reflective thought, questioning its feasibility and importance for maternal thinking. In some ways it could be classified as part of an outlaw genre, not belonging to the genre of academic philosophical writing or.
Reconceptualizing work and building ruddicks feminist. Fortunately, feminist care ethics has provided a source for thinking dependency and care in a different way. Philosophy chapter 5 true and false flashcards quizlet. Sara ruddicks theory of maternal thinking applied to. I argue that if maternal arguments do no address the varie. If you believed that establishing an american colonial government in some south american country would benefit the native people and protect the environment, would you support colonialism. Rumsey sara ruddicks maternal thinking represents a great contribution to moral philosophyin particular, by bringing womens private virtues into the public sphere. Solved ruddick theorized that maternal thinking affects. Ruddick then proposes, using far more passion than reason, that mothering be seen. The concept of maternal thinking was put forward in philosopher sara ruddick s 1989 book maternal thinking. The women and war reader by lorentzen, lois ann, 1952. Then later you made strong claimseven mentioning foucault and hegel etc.
Toward a politics of peace sara ruddick a new york times notable book of the year 1989philosopher, mother, and feminist sara ruddick examines the discipline of mothering, showing for the first time how the daytoday work of raising children gives rise to distinctive ways of thinking. Hanen and nielsen 4 sara ruddick maternal thinking 4 see. However, there remain problems in the analysis which need to be addressed. Constructing maternal thinking constructing maternal thinking rumsey, jean p. Sara ruddick, notes toward a feminist maternal peace politics. I argue that if maternal arguments do no address the variety of relationships race and class have to institutional violence and to the military, then maternal peace politics can only draw incomplete conclusions about the relationships between maternal workthinking and peace. Reflections on sara ruddicks maternal thinking request pdf.
1233 331 840 118 494 1227 49 1428 1374 740 467 522 35 610 251 320 81 337 624 281 877 1079 333 348 934 68 514 442 1492 236 271 503 498 63